Stadler Rail, the Swiss-based maker that already supplied locomotives for Uruguay's Ferrocarril Central, told the Senate Transport and Public Works Committee that a tram-train for Montevideo would cost about $300 million less than the government's electric bus plan over 30 years, la diaria reported on November 15.
Two shorter tram lines, no tunnels
The company would run surface trams, with no tunnels, on the same two main corridors the government has chosen, but on shorter routes: Ciudad Vieja to the Belloni interchange, and Ciudad Vieja to Costa Urbana Shopping. It would not go as far as Zonamérica or El Pinar, which Stadler says lack the demand. Trams would come every three and a half minutes, helped by traffic-signal priority. Stadler puts the investment at about $780 million and the works at roughly 30 months.
Stadler’s figures against the transport agency’s
The government plan uses electric bus rapid transit vehicles carrying 220 people each, reaches Zonamérica and El Pinar, and drops the tunnel under 18 de Julio. A September report by the metropolitan transport agency put the initial cost at $575 million for buses against $1,544 million for a tram, and $1,043 million against $2,096 million over 30 years.
Stadler disputes those figures. It accepts that a tram costs about $216 million more up front, but argues that trams last 25–30 years against 15 for buses, that bus batteries need replacing every five years at a cost of $144 million, and that one tram carries twice the passengers of a bus. The agency's own analysis sees staffing costs as roughly equal and the tram's upkeep as higher.
New studies due by March 2027
Transport Minister Lucía Etcheverry says new technical studies will be ready between December 2026 and March 2027, and the government still aims to deliver results by the end of 2029. The reform is at the conceptual design stage.
Montevideo still moves by bus for now
Nothing changes on the street yet. Getting around Montevideo still means the city's bus network, taxis and ride apps, and no new line is expected before the end of the decade. Our Montevideo guide covers how the city is laid out today.